Posts: 714
Thanks: 1312 in 35 Posts
8 Achievements
OK guys, heres comments from the last round and the final scores will be at the end... Sorry theres no judge three, that was me. :D
Mzcynnamon
Judge One: You did a very nice job of translating the floorplans into the Sims game; I also like how you emulated the exterior appearance to match the artist's rendering. Your backyard pond is lovely as well.
Judge Two: I love, love, love that you took this into a more contemporary, less cabin-y area! It looks great! Love the backyard but the loft's looking a little big.
I.nfectious
Judge One: Your floorplan rendition is very nice and quite accurate to the plans. Your landscaping is lush and I really like your use of the green roof against the light wood exterior.
Judge Two: Very unique take on the landscaping! I also really like the wall of windows in the front!
TLAWBLIQUE360
Judge One: There are a few issues with the floorplan/overall architecture (e.g. the attic spaces should all have floors and the windows should be on the second story and not on a third). Your lovely exterior makes up for the minor issues with the floorplan.
Judge Two: Loving the windows! Yet another cabin-y lodge with a little edge but I'm missing the breakfast bar and the proportions of the second floor seem a little off.
Coldfloral
Judge One: Your floor layout is generally true to the plans, however the upstairs bedrooms feel rather cramped in their space. Your exterior is very lovely and I like how you've accented the wood with the palette of greenery in the landscaping.
Judge Two: A little bit *too* generic-woodsy-cabin. Give me something to look at!
CiaoAlora
Judge One: Your floorplan is very close to the original and it is interesting that you've made the extra two-tiled entry doors into the living room instead of windows. The exterior is nice and rustic feeling.
Judge Two: Also very generic-woody-cabin, but warmer and classic. Less dated.
Kat:
One - 53.5
Two - 52.5
Three - none
Final: 106
Mz:
One - 41
Two - 43.5
Three - 51
Final: 135.5
Inky:
One - 52
Two - 51
Three - 55
Final: 158
Tlaw:
One - 41
Two - 49
Three - 47
Final: 137
Cold:
One - 53
Two - 52.5
Three - 49
Final:154.5
Ciao:
One - 53.5
Two - 48
Three - 50
Final:151.5
Brooke:
One - 49
Two - 47
Three - none
Final: 96
Okay! So our winners are.....
Third CiaoAlora (151.5)
Second ColdFloral (154.5)
AAAAAND...
First Inky (158)
Good job guys! I hope you enjoyed the contest and I do apologize for being so disorganized! Inky, ColdFloral & CiaoAlora pm me for your prizes...