I found it quite interesting to see the Goths appear in Moonlight Falls. Frida made a return from The Sims 2, while Samuel and Olivia are completely new. Due to my fascination with this family, it got me thinking.

With the reappearance of Frida Goth, the theory that Lolita Goth (the unknown relative of the Goths) is her was dispelled. Unfortunately, it didn't actually clear up what her role in the family was. Remaining theories include that she was the first wife of Gunther Goth, the mother of Victor Goth, or the half-sibling of Gunther and Frida who died. The most likely theory is that she was Gunther's first wife, due to the fact she died of electrocution and no electronics are present in the Goth home.

It also introduced the question as to whether Samuel Goth is the brother of Victor or Gretle. Due to no parents of either Victor or Gretle being shown in the family tree, for all we know the surname "Goth" could have originated from Gretle Goth. While unlikely due to the females' tendency to take the man's last name in the Goth family, it is a possibility. The reverse could also be said and that Olivia may be Gretle's sister, and both Victor and Samuel took their last name of Goth.

Wondering if anyone else had another idea or theory about who Lolita Goth was or who Samuel and Olivia are in relation to the Goths we know and love from Sunset Valley/Pleasantview.

Lolita Goth is discussed here:
http://linna.modthesims.info/showthread.php?t=356952

It's a really old thread though, just saying. There is a wiki page with a couple of theories http://sims.wikia.com/wiki/Lolita_Goth (: & http://sims.wikia.com/wiki/Goth_Family

Personally I think she was gunthers first wife, but obviously we won't know until EA clears it up. <3

Yes I noticed that however the thread was old and the last reply was before Supernatural was released. Isn't bumping old threads discouraged?

Hopefully EA will clear up their random Goth creation eventually lol.

After reading one theory on the wiki, I've made my final decision just that fast. I'm just guessing she shares the Goth surname, since she isn't on the family tree. Then again, I wouldn't put somebody's remains in my backyard just because they share my last name...

Touché, EA...touché.

In my game I think I made her Victor Goth's sister - because I wanted her on the family tree somewhere.

Not if it's related and additional info.

So, imo your post is related to the other one and your post was additional info.