So,
I noticed this today when I was playing my family who has two cats, Bonkers and Sasha. I am able to call Bonkers to eat but not Sasha.
Then I tested it on other families and in another family which has one dog and two cats I wasn't able to call the cats to eat but with the dog it was fine.

So I did the game problem thing. I removed Downloads and SavedSims and did a test but I still had the same problem. I removed all user files and I tested it with the Kat family. I was able to call the two older cats to eat but not the kitten.
I made the Roth family adopt two cats, one kitten and one adult. I had no luck calling them to eat.

I don't know what to do. I haven been downloading a lot of stuff but like I said, I removed the download folder to see if that was the problem but it didn't fix it.
I have patched my game too!
What's wrong? :/

In order to better solve your problem, please go through the following as listed below:

• General - Do the Game Problem FAQ
  You appear to have not gone through our main Game Help:Game Problem^wiki FAQ. Please go through and do the steps on this FAQ, including any others that it links to (for example the Game Help:Game Problem-Problem Custom Content^wiki FAQ).
  
  Usually, in the vast majority of cases, actually going through and doing the steps (doing, not just reading) fixes issues - sometimes you may be asked to remove custom content, or to patch - please rest assured that all of our FAQs have been tested by our staff and volunteers and we wouldn't suggest you do something unless it's been known to fix particular issues.
  

Have you tried a new user account and failing that, a full clean reinstall?

On occasion you might be asked to do a long FAQ - please make sure you do all the steps and don't just skip over them. You'll often find that these long FAQs have all the details you need. If nothing in the above FAQs fixes your problem you may post again detailing exactly which you have done and which steps failed.